Winsipedia - College Football Statistics and History
WINSIPEDIA

1896: 2 Champions, Zero Agreement

SPLIT

Lafayette and Princeton both finished with one tie and no losses, and while the National Championship Foundation named them co-champions, the Helms Athletic Foundation picked Princeton alone.

The case for each side

Princeton college football team logo

Princeton

10-0-1
Recognized byHAFRetroactiveNCFRetroactive

10-0-1, tied Lafayette 0-0; named sole national champion by the Billingsley Report, Helms Athletic Foundation, and Houlgate System, and co-national champion (with Lafayette) by the National Championship Foundation and Parke H. Davis.

Princeton’s 1896 schedule
Lafayette college football team logo

Lafayette

11-0-1
Recognized byNCFRetroactive

11-0-1, tied Princeton 0-0; named co-national champion (with Princeton) only by the National Championship Foundation and Parke H. Davis, not by Helms.

Lafayette’s 1896 schedule

No national title game was played after the 1896 season: before 1998 there was no mechanism to play one, which is why so many of these seasons were settled by vote instead.

1896 College Football National Championship: Princeton or Lafayette? - Winsipedia